Captive insurance: turning industrial risk into a strategic asset

Some of the largest industrial groups own an insurer of their own, set up for one purpose only: to cover the group’s risks. This is the captive insurer.

In Europe, captives cluster in a handful of specialist domiciles, Luxembourg among them. Over the past few years, three major Italian groups have brought their captives home, in transactions approved by IVASS between 2023 and 2024.

12 

new reinsurers licensed in Luxembourg in 2025 (Commissariat aux Assurances)

2009 

the year since which Italy had no supervised specialist reinsurer until the captives returned (IVASS)

3 

Italian groups’ captives redomiciled to Italy (Eni, Enel, Prysmian)

30/1/2027 

application date of the Solvency II review under Directive (EU) 2025/2 (Article 4), via national transposition

An insurer in the family

A captive is an insurance or reinsurance undertaking owned by a non-insurance group (a non-financial company, or a financial company other than an insurer or reinsurer) and whose sole purpose is to cover the risks of the group. The word “captive” is also used in other industries for companies that serve only their own group; this article is concerned solely with captive insurers and reinsurers as defined in insurance legislation.

The definition comes from Directive 2009/138/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 November 2009, better known as Solvency II (Article 13, points 2 and 5). Italy’s Private Insurance Code adopts it, speaking of a “controlled” undertaking (Legislative Decree No. 209 of 7 September 2005, Article 1(1)(u-bis) and (cc-bis)).

Read strictly, the rule ties a captive’s purpose to the group’s own risks; taking on risks from outside the group could therefore cost it its captive status.

A captive is not an internal rainy-day fund. It is a licensed and supervised insurer like any other: its capital, governance and public disclosure all follow Solvency II, with some simplifications. The simplest model is the pure captive: a single owner insuring its own risks and those of its subsidiaries (IAIS, Application Paper on the Regulation and Supervision of Captive Insurers, November 2015, paragraphs 4 and 8).

What captives insure

At the heart of a captive’s book are the group’s physical assets: plants, facilities and warehouses. This is property business, covering damage from fire, natural perils and other losses. In the three captives of Italian industrial groups that publish a solvency and financial condition report (SFCR), property damage makes up between 77% and 88% of 2025 gross written premiums (in one case together with credit). Around this core sit the other lines: business interruption, third-party liability, goods in transit and credit.

The exception is a travel group’s captive, where traveller-related expenses dominate.

For the supervisors that make up the IAIS, one distinction matters most: risks that stay within the group, such as property damage, versus risks that involve third parties, such as liability (IAIS, Application Paper on the Regulation and Supervision of Captive Insurers, November 2015, paragraphs 10-11).

How it works

A captive can insure group companies directly or reinsure risks that a commercial insurer, the fronting insurer, has written for the group (IAIS, Application Paper, paragraphs 11-12). Either way, it can pass on to reinsurers whatever share of the risk it prefers not to keep.

Why groups set one up

Why would a group want an insurer of its own? The European Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority (EIOPA) is clear: a captive is a cost-efficient risk financing tool, allowing the group to secure cover and to pool the risks of its companies (EIOPA, Opinion on the supervision of captive (re)insurance undertakings, EIOPA-BoS-24/176 of 2 July 2024, paragraph 2.3, p. 4). Two further potential benefits stand out: 

  • cost control, since the group no longer pays an external insurer’s margin, 
  • and the scope for tailor-made cover for complex risks.

There is a flip side. Setting up a captive takes a substantial upfront investment and an authorisation process with the supervisor. Once up and running, the captive must meet risk-based capital requirements and reporting and disclosure obligations to the supervisor and the market. It also needs sound governance and a solid technical set-up.

Where they are domiciled

There is no official list: the EIOPA register does not flag captives. Luxembourg is today the EU’s largest captive reinsurance market. There are official signs of interest, too: Luxembourg’s supervisor licensed 12 new reinsurers in 2025 and reported renewed appetite for captive reinsurance.

The rules of the game

The rules sit at several levels. The Solvency II Directive has to be transposed by each Member State. Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35 of 10 October 2014, by contrast, is directly applicable, and already lets captives use simplified capital calculations, provided they insure only the group and write no compulsory third-party liability cover (Articles 88-90, 103, 105 and 106). In Italy, the Private Insurance Code and IVASS regulations add further requirements.

Governance in Italy. Like other insurers with their registered office in Italy, captives are subject to IVASS Regulation No. 38 of 3 July 2018 on the system of governance (Article 3(1)(a) and (c)). Undertakings must have “an adequate system of governance, proportionate to the nature, scale and complexity of the risks, current and prospective, inherent in their business” (Article 4(1)). To apply proportionality, the IVASS Letter to the Market of 5 July 2018 sets out three governance models: “enhanced”, “ordinary” and “simplified”. The board selects the model on the basis of quantitative thresholds and qualitative factors.

Under the “simplified” model, an undertaking may, among other things, do without an Internal Control and Risk Committee and a Remuneration Committee, merge the units running the risk-management, compliance and actuarial functions, and outsource its key functions. Where it belongs to an insurance group (Article 210-ter(2) of the Private Insurance Code), it is expected, after careful assessment, to outsource them to another group company. The choice of model is not automatic: it turns on the quantitative and qualitative features of the business.

EIOPA has asked national supervisors to focus on three areas: cash pooling with the group, prudent investment and governance (EIOPA-BoS-24/176, paragraphs 3.1-3.22).

What the review could change

The Solvency II review (Directive (EU) 2025/2 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 27 November 2024) leaves the definition of a captive unchanged in Article 13 of Directive 2009/138/EC. It does, however, bring in proportionality measures that, once transposed, could lighten captives’ obligations. Most of them hinge on two conditions: policyholders and beneficiaries must be group entities or, up to less than 5% of technical provisions, individuals covered by group policies; and the business must not include compulsory third-party liability insurance. As these are directive provisions, what follows reflects the European text only. Whether, and how far, the measures will apply in Italy will depend on the transposing legislative decree, not yet adopted, and on IVASS’s implementing rules.

On classification, a captive meeting both conditions may be classified as a small and non-complex undertaking by notifying its supervisor, which may object within the time limits set by the Directive (Article 29a(1) and Article 29b(3) and (5)).

On periodic requirements, subject to the same two conditions, the Directive provides for an exemption from reporting more frequently than annually (Article 35a(3)) and allows the own risk and solvency assessment (ORSA) to be carried out at least every two years, provided it is repeated after any significant change in the risk profile (Article 45(5)(b)).

On public disclosure, captives may publish a simplified SFCR limited to quantitative data. Captive reinsurers must meet two additional conditions: loans to the parent or to other group companies, cash pooling included, may not exceed 20% of the captive’s total assets; and the maximum loss arising from technical provisions must be measurable deterministically, without stochastic models (Article 51(3) and (4)).

As for the external audit of the SFCR, the Directive does not require it for captives but lets Member States extend it to them (Article 51a(1) and (2)). Italy’s European Delegation Law asks the Government to take up this option, as explained in the section on transposition.

Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/269 of 29 October 2025, which amends Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35, is a different matter: as a regulation, it applies directly across all Member States from 30 January 2027, with no transposition needed.

Italy and transposition

The Government’s mandate comes from the 2024 European Delegation Law (Law No. 91 of 13 June 2025, Article 13(14)), within the time limits, procedures and general principles set by Law No. 234 of 24 December 2012 (Articles 31 and 32). One decision has already been taken: the law requires captives as well to have their SFCR balance sheet audited (Article 13(15)(a)), using the option in Article 51a(2) of the Directive. IVASS must issue its rules within 180 days of each decree entering into force or, if later, of the European Commission adopting the delegated acts (Article 13(16)).

The transposition deadline is 29 January 2027. On 29 September 2026 the Government sent the draft decree (Government Act No. 443) to the Chamber of Deputies for its opinion. The draft extends the statutory auditor’s review to the SFCR of captive insurers. Until the decree and IVASS’s implementing rules are adopted, the practical impact of the new measures on Italian captives remains to be seen.

Italian captives come home

Three major groups have made the same move: Eni, Enel and Prysmian have brought their captives back to Italy through cross-border mergers approved by IVASS between 2023 and 2024.

IVASS noted that no supervised specialist reinsurer had operated in Italy since 2009, and described the redomiciliations as a way for groups to manage their risks more efficiently (IVASS, Relazione sull’attività svolta dall’Istituto nell’anno 2024 [Annual report on 2024 activities], 19 June 2025, pp. 12 and 97). Other groups keep their captives abroad: Snam and Alpitour in Ireland, Amplifon and Mediobanca (Compass RE) in Luxembourg (EIOPA register).

New risks on the radar

Cyber, artificial intelligence, natural catastrophes, geopolitical tension, inflation and import costs: EIOPA counts them among the key risks and vulnerabilities facing the insurance sector. AI widens cyber exposure and makes it harder to price; more frequent and more severe natural catastrophes make closing the protection gap more pressing; non-life business remains exposed to claims inflation; and reinsurers themselves are exposed to catastrophes, geopolitics and cyber events (EIOPA, Financial Stability Report, June 2026, pp. 8-9).

For a captive, these factors bear on three stages.

  1. Risk selection: the groups reviewed take different approaches, from placing catastrophe and cyber risks in the captive to buying cyber cover in the market.
  2. Risk management: catastrophe risk can become the largest component of the capital requirement, and inflation can shift premium and reserve estimates.
  3. Risk acceptance and transfer: cyber risk is hard to model and reinsurers are exposed to the same events, which makes protecting the captive more complex (2025 SFCRs and group annual reports; EIOPA, Financial Stability Report, June 2026, pp. 8-9).

What to watch

  • The transposing decree and IVASS rules, which will determine the simplifications available in Italy (deadline: 29 January 2027).
  • The SFCR audit, which the European Delegation Law requires to be extended to captives.
  • The 20% cap on loans and cash pooling to the group.
  • The Commission’s adoption of the technical standards on reporting and the SFCR, proposed by EIOPA in its final report EIOPA-BoS-26/081 of 30/3/2026.

How Forvis Mazars can help

Forvis Mazars has extensive experience working with industrial groups and with captive insurers and reinsurers in Italy and across Europe. Our team brings together legal, regulatory, actuarial, risk-management, accounting and tax expertise to support captives across their entire life cycle, from first-line operations to second- and third-line control functions.

Design, set-up and relocation

We help groups with the initial choices and with extraordinary transactions:

  • feasibility studies and choice of domicile;
  • operating model design: direct writing, reinsurance, use of a fronting insurer;
  • business plan and licence application to IVASS;
  • redomiciliation to Italy, including cross-border mergers and the related changes to the articles of association.

Governance and internal control framework

We help captives apply IVASS Regulation No. 38 of 3 July 2018:

  • choosing the governance model (“enhanced”, “ordinary” or “simplified”) under the IVASS Letter to the Market of 5 July 2018;
  • role and functioning of the board and its committees;
  • internal control and risk-management system: segregation of duties, reporting lines, data management;
  • reinsurance, capital management and remuneration policies;
  • fit and proper requirements for directors, senior managers and key function holders;
  • outsourcing policy and oversight of outsourced activities.

First line: technical, accounting, investment and actuarial management

We can support the captive’s operating team on:

  • technical and accounting management: underwriting, claims, reinsurance and fronting programmes, financial statements;
  • investment and liquidity management in line with the prudent person principle, with particular attention to intra-group arrangements such as cash pooling;
  • calculation of technical provisions under Solvency II and IVASS Regulation No. 18 of 15 March 2016: segmentation of obligations, best estimate and risk margin, setting and documenting the underlying assumptions, data quality.

Second and third line: the key functions

We can support, including on an outsourced basis, the functions required by IVASS Regulation No. 38/2018:

  • risk management and the own risk and solvency assessment (ORSA), under IVASS Regulation No. 32 of 9 November 2016;
  • compliance;
  • the actuarial function, which coordinates the calculation of technical provisions, assesses the appropriateness of methods, assumptions and data, and gives an opinion on underwriting policy and reinsurance arrangements (Directive 2009/138/EC, Article 48);
  • internal audit.

Regulatory change

We track the transposition of the Solvency II review in Italy to help captives assess its impact early: from possible classification as a small and non-complex undertaking to proportionality measures and the SFCR audit.

All services are provided in line with applicable independence requirements, in particular where Forvis Mazars is also the statutory auditor.

Want to know more?

Contact us

Want to know more?